The standardised super-peak hedge product

electricity consulting
image
Ruyi Jia, Dr Eilya Torshizian

Bringing Transparency and Liquidity to Aotearoa’s Electricity Hedge Market

Principal Economics is delighted to release our new report for the Electricity Authority, evaluating market-making parameters for a standardised super‑peak hedge contract. This analysis supports regulatory design that promotes price transparency, market liquidity, and robust consumer outcomes.

Key Findings

  • Tiered Spread Cap Recommendation: We suggest a responsive cap structure with a 3.5% spread during normal conditions, and up to 8% during high-volatility or stress periods, ensuring a balance between affordability for hedge-takers and sustainable participation by market makers.
  • Optimal Quote Depth Identified: Market-maker net benefits peak between 10–15 MW of quote depth. Beyond this range, marginal benefits decline, reflecting diminishing returns.
  • Evidence-Based Elasticity Insights: Regression results show that in high-volatility environments, a 1% increase in volatility increases spreads by ~0.37%, while doubling depth lowers spreads by ~8%, highlighting the trade-off between risk and liquidity.
  • Real-World Spread Benchmarking: Analysis of super‑peak auction data reveals median effective spreads around 3%, with the 95th percentile reaching 9–10%, supporting the recommended cap framework.
  • Policy Framework Based on an Optimal Frontier: We apply an optimal frontier approach, plotting trade-offs between spread and depth to identify efficient market-making combinations. These choices deliver targeted liquidity at minimal cost—supporting the Electricity Authority’s public-interest objectives.

Why This Matters

The findings inform regulatory calibration of market-making in New Zealand’s super-peak hedge markets—helping ensure resilience amid volatility and price shocks, while avoiding onerous caps that stifle market participation. Our evidence-based design framework is meant to support durable, fair, and cost-conscious policy choices.


Read the full report for a comprehensive breakdown of our methodology, data, simulations, and policy implications: Download the report PDF here.